The Zimmerman Case: Not About Racism

zimmerman300Let me offer a different take on the George Zimmerman case. I don’t think it was about racism or racial profiling.

Sure, the media quickly spun the shooting as racism, and President Obama firmly implanted racist themes when he (unwisely) weighed in. But I don’t think Zimmerman was motivated by racism. I think it was far more primal–a guy thing.

I think George Zimmerman was a no-account fellow going through life powerless, unrecognized, invisible. But having a gun made him feel like a Big Man. And with gun in hand, he could pursue his fantasies of being Someone to be Reckoned With. For his little neighborhood, he wanted to be perceived as Jack Nicholson’s Man on the Wall. Protector of Society. A man to be appreciated and respected. And having a gun put all of that within reach.

So when Zimmerman saw someone traipsing through the neighborhood who didn’t seem to belong–well, it didn’t matter if the guy was white or black or in between. And it didn’t matter that the police told him to stay in his car, to not approach. Zimmerman was overpowered with a macho fantasy to fulfill. This was a situation he had dreamed about. He needed to ride to the rescue, gun in hand, and save the day…and win the applause of his protectees.

And so, Zimmerman blundered in, and things went badly.

Was it self-defense? Maybe. Did Martin attack him first? Maybe. But it wasn’t racism that started the thing rolling. It was a guy who carried a gun without understanding the responsibilities that go with it.

(I could be totally wrong. It’s happened before.)

Share Button

2 Comments to The Zimmerman Case: Not About Racism

  1. Jeff Bleijerveld

    You bring up an excellent point. While the media and public would like to make this about all sorts of things, it probably has more to do with one man’s lack of fore thought and self-control. Now that he has had his moment in the limelight and has been relegated to a lifetime of constantly looking over his shoulder, I wonder if he might be wishing he had just let the whole thing go. Had he known then what he knows now, he might have thought less of an unknown stranger walking through his neighborhood at 7:00 pm.

  2. Russel Trojan

    I am amazed at how many people want and try to attribute motive to Mr. Zimmerman. It is pure fantasy and counter-productive (and we won’t mention the defamation part). The things I read indicated that Mr. Zimmerman was heading back to his vehicle when he was attacked. That does not sound anything like a “man on a mission”. ALL the evidence says that as a member of the Neighborhood Watch, Mr. Zimmerman was WATCHING.

    His position in court was self defense and the jury agreed with him. That makes young Mr. Martin the aggressor; in hindsight rather foolish, but the aggressor nonetheless.

    This type of dishonest speculation only fuels an already inflamed situation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Receive Posts by Email

If you subscribe to my Feedburner feed, you'll automatically receive new posts by email. Very convenient.



Monthly Archives